Skip to main content

Real Talk: Poet Cannot Answer 8th Grade Reading Questions About Her Own Work


Time for some REAL talk.

Sara Holbrook published a wildly viral article on Huffington Post wherein she criticizes the 8th grade STAAR for its author's purpose questions on two of her poems. Holbrook brings her incisive commentary to bear on the long running issue of standardized testing - with the unique twist of actually being an author. She's got a strong platform to stand on, and she uses it to condemn standardized testing and those who utilize it.

 Read her article here

We at Real Talk Intervention beg to disagree. Please check out our special podcast on this issue, where we take issue with her contention that the questions are useless because they failed to correctly identify her purpose, and with her overall thesis that standardized tests such as these are useless for parents, educators, and students alike.

Listen to our podcast here.

We apologize for the audio quality on this one guys - there were some technical issues we weren't able to fully overcome.

Please follow us on Facebook
We are on Twitter @Intervene4Real

We are currently working to get our podcasts up on iTunes - there's been some more technical glitches there as well.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Texas Holds Students With Disabilities to a Higher Standard on State Exams

Let’s just call it like it is. 2016-2017 was not a great year for student assessment in Texas. Between the scandal of mis-graded STAAR tests, graders hired for peanuts on Craigslist, and large numbers of parents and students conscientiously objecting to even taking part in our state’s annual testing rituals, many Texans have been left wondering where, exactly, IS the accountability in our state accountability system.    But if there is one person who is keenly aware of where the accountability is, it’s the high school senior who’s taking a STAAR End of Course test. That senior needs to pass that test in order to graduate in that same month. That student is painfully aware that the STAAR test doesn’t care where he grew up, or who her parents are, or whether he is dyslexic or learning disabled or gifted and talented. Regardless of what challenges she faced or what advantages he received, everyone all sits down and takes the exact same test. That’s what TEA promises. All stude...
1 comment
Read more

Episode 24: Why do you STAY a teacher?

All of us have been asked the question at one point or another. What made you decide to become a teacher? You've been asked it in job interviews, where the right answer seemed critical. You've been asked it by incredulous family members, where the right answer seemed impossible. You've been asked it by students, where the right answer seemed loaded. We've all got our response memorized. Whether that response reflects your deeply felt, inspirational path into the classroom, the safe-for-work, sanitized version of your winding road towards respectability, or is simply a rehearsed tale that carefully avoids saying "I don't know why I do half the things I do." I don't know about you, but I'm bored by my story. It's not particularly inspirational, and, frankly, it's not particularly interesting. You want to see into a teacher's soul? Don't ask us why we started. Ask us why we  stay .  Why do we stay in a career that...
3 comments
Read more

Blog Post: Why do you stay?

I don’t make sweeping generalizations because they are always wrong, but if you are a teacher, people have wondered why you actually do that. The curiosity about WHY on EARTH you would choose this profession is so deep-seated that we even ask it of each other in job interviews. I mean think about that for a second. Can you imagine at NASA: “So Christina, why did you decide to become an astronaut?” Sitting before the medical review board: “What motivated you to become a neurosurgeon?” I guess I don’t really know – perhaps they do ask that sort of question, but it just feels kind of unlikely. My husband’s an electrical engineer who works on fighter planes, and I promise you he has never had to justify to anyone why he chose THAT particular career path. Yet I have justified my career path to everyone from job interviews to grant applications to friends at cocktail parties, and every single time everyone’s left feeling unsatisfied. I can feel them want...
Post a Comment
Read more